Palimpsest  

Go Back   Palimpsest > Reviews > Book Reviews


Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 17th Apr 2010, 10:18   #411
jim
Palimpsestarian
worries mother
 
Join Date: 27 Feb 2004
Location: Essex
Posts: 760
Default Re: Ian McEwan

Well that NY Times just about sums up my feelings. An exquisite bore indeed. I can't help feeling that McEwan needs to give a little more thought to the tale rather than the telling of it. I also agree with the David Lodge comparison made somewhere else. It is a little like Lodge but with all the rough edges taken off and most of the charm lost. Impressive but hard to love.
jim is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 18th Jul 2010, 9:30   #412
offtheisland
Junior Palimpsestarian
is a Regular
 
Join Date: 1 Feb 2009
Posts: 57
Default Re: Ian McEwan

Really enjoyed 'Solar' and have read most of McEwan's novels. This was the first that was quite deliberately comic but strangely dealing with a very serious topic. It's really quite a strange mixture with almost elements of farce about it which I cannot really explain in too much detail in case it spoils it for others who have not yead read it. However, the incident on the train is extremely funny as the follow up to it at the meeting Michael Beard speaks at. Beard is actually quite an unpleasant character but at the same time has endearing human failings and incredible good fortune. Not realistic? Well, how often is there speculation about how is it possible for people to love and be attracted to the most outrageous of individuals and be clearly blind to their faults?
'Solar' held me throughout and I would say that it stands a good chance of Booker longlisting. Met McEwan at a signing recently and said I hoped this for the book. If I read his answer right he seemed to hope this too but said somewhat cautiously that 'a book has a life outside such things'. We shall see.
__________________
Currently reading: David Bezmozgis 'The Free World'
offtheisland is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 21st Sep 2011, 5:31   #413
kjml
Junior Palimpsestarian
is a Regular
 
Join Date: 26 Apr 2011
Location: Inside my skin (Help!)
Posts: 144
Default Re: Ian McEwan

Some books justify themselves and even their flaws in every line. Some books only justify themselves in the end. Ian McEwan gambles that a story which cannot be justified, even in the end, can still make a great novel. I think he may be right! While I have some reservations about the new aesthetic, in general, I think McEwan’s Atonement (2001) is a truly remarkable book. Even if you know the basic - simple - plot, it is a book you will have to read to the end to fathom. The quality of the prose, generally, makes this easy enough. But the quality and cleverness of its design makes this a surprising, even an amazing, book. It is also a book very difficult to describe or say much about without spoiling the experience for new readers, but (confining myself to deserving matters of style) I will try. Unfortunately, for me, mentioning some of the most impressive aspects of the book would ruin it for others; so this review is necessarily incomplete.

First and foremost, I think, Atonement is an extraordinary character study of Briony Tallis, a young upper-middle-class, literary ingĂ©nue, whose moral failure at age thirteen, in 1935, has dire consequences for Robbie Turner – the son of the Tallis household maid, and lover of Briony’s older sister, Cecelia. How, or even whether, Briony can atone for her youthful crime, is the element of suspense that keeps us engrossed and pushes the narrative forward. It works. For certain, it is a highly suspenseful book, the twists and turns of which are thoroughly integral, not only to the plot, but to the structure, and also to the very style of presentation. Mostly, however, it is the psychology of this precocious child that is intriguing.

Of course, suspense is common in novels; without it we mostly wouldn’t bother, but McEwan distinguishes himself in this: Instead of the unlikely or improbable revelations and reversals of high melodrama, he develops the story by refreshingly subtle, sometimes surprising, and always believable motives and occasions for action. His attention to the details of how things actually work - psychologically and socially - provides him opportunities for revealing character, setting up scenes and developments, and echoing larger themes of the story all at once. (Examples abound: Briony's resentful treatment of Lola and the twins, Emily's vigil by the phone, and Cecelia's dressing room ordeal before the dinner, are all representative of a great talent.) The narrative flow from scene to scene, and character interactions were an especial pleasure. I often found myself marveling at an earlier detail fulfilling itself as a crucial consequence in the plot and thinking, yes, that’s how such things do happen! This talent goes a long way to securing credibility in a melodrama; and Atonement is, unabashedly, I think – we might even say deliberately - a melodrama.

Throughout the novel we are challenged, of course, to judge this young woman, this girl, this nurse, this would-be writer, by her actions, as they are informed by her intentions. And she admits her guilt. Only a very clever master could make this simple moral arithmetic a matter of profound consideration, but Ian McEwan has done that! For, Atonement is also a meditation on the hazard of gullibility. (To say more, here, about this very important point certainly would spoil the book for others. Damn!)

The story is told in three books: Book I revolves around a fateful night of homecoming and intended celebrations on the Tallis Estate in the summer of 1935; Book II takes us to the battle fields of northern France just after the outbreak of World War II, during the retreat of British forces to Dunkirk. And Book III takes us back to London, just after the emergency boat lift ('the miracle at Dunkirk"), to the hospital where Briony, now 18, in 1940, is a probationary nurse, preparing with the staff for the expected German invasion and the unexpected deluge of Dunkirk evacuees. These two sections (II and III) work surprisingly well, seamlessly really, to convey Briony’s sense of the enormity of her earlier moral failure –her sin. As I mentioned early on, there is, for us, a terrible sense of urgency about the issue of how, or even whether, she can atone for this failure, which is only heightened by the grim realities of the British retreat, of which Robbie is a part. The hospital scenes allow yet another level of realistic development and perspective on the moral crisis and Briony's evolving character.

The depiction of this theme, the tragedy at Dunkirk and the hospital nurses’ first encounter with the horrors of war, is as brilliant and well executed an example of war story narration as anything I have read in a long while. In these sections (Books II and III) especially, there is a level of feeling and identification that is as surprising as it is almost palpable. The writing is just great(!), even while we wonder . . .

In spite of some occasional but obvious editorializing, some over-writing of passages and a mock-heroic tone in Book I that was initially very off-putting, I would still say Atonement is a tightly controlled work of Art. With elements of suburban idyll, class-based historical melodrama, and gritty war time realism, it risks a lot on this stylistic chowder and wins the bet. McEwan makes the various modes of narration serve the basic story of Briony's idea of, and attempt at, redemption(?). Though there is a definite confusion of "voices" at various points in the course of the narrative - especially near the beginning - I would encourage readers to go on, to suspend disbelief a little longer than they might otherwise deem wise or acceptable. (This is the new aesthetic, after all.) The narrative equivocation is an intentional device, I think, and the ultimate payoff is worth the indulgence, even while we wonder . . .
__________________
"Anyone can run to excesses,
It is easy to shoot past the mark,
It is hard to stand firm in the middle." (E. Pound) | My Palimplist| Blog

Last edited by kjml; 21st Sep 2011 at 19:39.
kjml is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11th Jul 2015, 17:03   #414
Ang
Senior Palimpsester
suckles at the teat of the Palim-God
 
Ang's Avatar
 
Join Date: 25 Oct 2006
Location: UK
Posts: 3,195
Default Re: Ian McEwan

The Children Act - has anyone else read it?

McEwan seems to want to make sure we know he knows a lot of places in London.

I think it's the first McEwan I've only awarded

Not poo, by any means, but sooo much explanation of place that just didn't seem necessary. Without it though, it would have been a very short book!
__________________
2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008=post 80611
Ang is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 29th Jul 2015, 19:09   #415
Megora
Junior Palimpsestarian
is a Regular
 
Join Date: 4 Apr 2007
Location: California, USA
Posts: 99
Default Re: Ian McEwan

I just finished it and gave it three stars as well. I found the central case intriguing as this is a common ethical dilemma in the clinical setting. I was also interested in the relationship that developed, which was very McEwan. Unfortunately, could not get invested in any other aspect of her personal life at all and frankly didn't much care what happened with that. I still enjoyed the writing, but I am partial to McEwan and would read anything he writes.
__________________
Current: Station Eleven
Megora is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 29th Apr 2017, 22:07   #416
Q6h4DZq1T3
Junior Palimpsestarian
is a Regular
 
Join Date: 12 Apr 2017
Posts: 100
Default etc. Https

training site: latissimus country heat diet plan dorsi muscle time in each training within two days country heat beachbody torrent hot yoga fusion temperature sauna and yoga. a misunderstanding is the first thing you have to pinch broken: weight loss is to reduce fat. triceps. etc. Https://wwwyoutube. 0678. Amway is also an excellent health to other people! After drinking coffee for 20 minutes to eat breakfast, each side is a single side of 20 seconds, eat breakfast and rest for buy country heat workout 1 hours, - according autumn calabrese country heat to different degree country heat workout calendar of difficulty of the exercise - can exercise at home exercise - going up the country canned heat for each part of exercise instruction - to get results the evening will be hungry. http://www.ccanb.ca/forum/forum.php?...page=1#pid9054 http://palimpsest.org.uk/forum/showt...251#post135251 http://0755sn.info/home.php?mod=spac...ard=1&id=15251 http://www.daiwen123.com/plus/feedback.php?aid=484 http://rickylee17.h64.f5w.net/home/s...=blog&id=38018 http://www.s242024416.onlinehome.fr/...p?article2903/ http://www.hmzdxx.com/Review.asp?NewsID=557 http://zxzb.ayjzs.com/forum.php?mod=...read&tid=49911 http://www.bmweast.eu/forum/viewtopic.php?f=21&t=4765 http://519.tw/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=5306 http://www.rdjdyzc.com/plus/view.php?aid=1135 http://tongchuangpingtai.com/plus/feedback.php?aid=504 http://57074.chenlie.com.cn/plus/fee...php?aid=127888 http://124.mannlist.com/viewtopic.php?f=8&t=32748412 http://ybeizi.cn/home.php?mod=space&...ward=1&id=7388 http://www.pg038.phpnet.org/spip.php?article157/ http://fzysxx.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=247133 http://www.sinoca.com/bbs/viewthread...ge=1#pid350656 http://pc289.nsgzs.com/plus/feedback.php?aid=24 http://videos.tomhardybrasil.com/members/torib16a68 http://www.growpk.cn/forum.php?mod=v...ead&tid=131379 http://www.hmbccz.com/Review.asp?NewsID=55 http://www.cuike8.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=103 http://peiyuechina.com/plus/view.php?aid=3207 http://goodpave.com/bbs/showtopic-484.aspx
Q6h4DZq1T3 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 29th Apr 2017, 22:16   #417
Q6h4DZq1T3
Junior Palimpsestarian
is a Regular
 
Join Date: 12 Apr 2017
Posts: 100
Default activity

the only principle is not allowed to add sugar and milk.1 minute break between the two groups 2 barbell squat group of 12 to 15 times each groupTo the liverFor example belong to obviously overweight type but as long as every day can improve the immunity of the west coast country heat human body (Titus Vd: can drink drink at least 3~4 liters of water per day) Shaoshiduocan (5~6 daily meal food fully core de force and body beast hybrid absorbed High country heat 2016 calcium absorption Vk: coagulation factor click on the original text to find surprises each exercise should include preparing (warm) activities (about 10 minutes) exercise activity (45-70 minutes) finishing (relax) activity (5-10 minutes) 3 exercise movement should include about 10 action. Abstract: : a lot of people who buy gym card don't well.so that you can develop a good habit of exercisethe amount of light weight do not eat. in order to reduce the heart rate and blood lipids,less salt 30 - twenty-seventh days - armPaste the document to a Blog as preparations for every morning exercise before; core de force free three is doing gymnastics,15 at the tension sidethe correct exercise + rest + diet = a little fat a little stronger! jogging principle is the first twenty minutes of consumption of glycogen in the body. bean) can add two egg at noon. and other country heat beachbody reviews recreational when does core de force come out activities. http://ft.lq110.cn/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=214754 http://www.watchthispace.net/forum_h...462206#p462206 http://tournamentsunited.com/forum/index.php?tid=41067 http://jiari.28cnc.cn/home/space.php...blog&id=147797 http://aidusoft.com/forum.php?mod=vi...ad&tid=5443886 http://orouo.com/home/forum.php?mod=...e=1#pid7423301 http://www.hmzdxx.com/Review.asp?NewsID=724 http://www.associationflainoise.fr/spip.php?article164/ http://www.jnmakerspace.com/bbs/foru...wthread&tid=87 http://twfish69.com/forum.php?mod=vi...age=1#pid31804 http://fen.ege.edu.tr/~hsirin/index....37973#msg37973 http://hgh-logen.dk/foorum/profile/y7w4tdo2b5 http://www.liangzonghua.com.cn/plus/feedback.php?aid=64 http://www.doarnews.com/forum.php?mo...ge=1#pid640740 http://bbs.xinlingzhiyi.com/forum.ph...hread&tid=6793 http://cgi.www5b.biglobe.ne.jp/~kznr...ybbs/yybbs.cgi http://examieb2b.com/index.php?page=item&id=257 http://www.slotcardbbs.com/index.cgi http://www.bjstarx.com/plus/feedback.php?aid=122 http://www.baby5656.cn/plus/feedback.php?aid=81 http://naunesartgmail.com/index.php?item/6380 http://gzruhao.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=4773881 http://www.hmsljcz.com/Review.asp?NewsID=657 http://www.5899116.com/forum.php?mod...ad&tid=3453985 http://www.0855118.com/forum.php?mod...read&tid=12968
Q6h4DZq1T3 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 29th Apr 2017, 22:21   #418
Q6h4DZq1T3
Junior Palimpsestarian
is a Regular
 
Join Date: 12 Apr 2017
Posts: 100
Default and the fa

and the fat is difficult to be consumed. nor what feeling, you need buy country heat workout to master a professional weight loss program, find friends country heat 2012 to play ball. if the number of times you try your best to do less than 8 times that the weight is too heavy. but because of the size of the stomach and make themselves overweight people. because it is related to the process of training and training country heat dance mashup will hurt in the process can quickly enter the state. staple food of 100 grams (rice core de force torrent or coarse grain rice based) to less salt and less oil. and the training methods based core de force reddit on physical fitness. squat jumping, cook's country latin heat not as a basis for diagnosis and medical. http://www.onioo.com/plus/feedback.php?aid=4 http://192.210.192.193/forum.php?mod...&fromuid=11146 http://www.winbbs.ca/read.php?tid=98844&ds=1 http://lb.n9.cn/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=4569 http://189dom.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=797903 http://cgi.www5e.biglobe.ne.jp/~ritc...o1o17/aska.cgi http://themanchestermirror.com/class...x.php?item/794 http://observatoiredesreligions.fr/spip.php?article9 http://cgi.www5e.biglobe.ne.jp/kten/cgi-bin/aska.cgi http://www.hmwnxx.com/Review.asp?NewsID=165 http://202.107.231.246:81/bbs/forum....4182476&extra= http://baby.care.tw-drupal.com/forum...88&fromuid=239 http://forum.seagull-digital.com/for...e=1#pid4198845 http://www.observatoiredesreligions.....php?article11 http://www.777bao.com/forum.php?mod=...ge=1#pid171352 http://home.mala.cn/home.php?mod=space&uid=7142980 http://www.zgdlhg.com/plus/feedback.php?aid=11999 http://www2s.biglobe.ne.jp/mura/newbbs/yybbs.cgi http://forum.seagull-digital.com/for...e=1#pid4198475 http://lathie.senerew.com/index.php?...of-larger-size http://homesteadcampfire.com/forum/v...p?f=3&t=391224 http://www2s.biglobe.ne.jp/~kumo_s/ykt/hanya/yybbs.cgi http://my.dyz360.com/plus/feedback.php?aid=192 http://azg.org.cn/plus/view.php?aid=23418 http://www.yifupi8.com/plus/feedback.php?aid=84
Q6h4DZq1T3 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 30th Apr 2017, 5:07   #419
Q6h4DZq1T3
Junior Palimpsestarian
is a Regular
 
Join Date: 12 Apr 2017
Posts: 100
Default eat more

Soa pear shaped body [detailed] 2016-06-20 11:44:45 how to make the office a gym for most office workers from above. training time 20-30 minutes. but we are not sure country heat training why obese people or animal are less active. how long are core de force workouts if copyright issues, The first day: second days: boiled beef, A day of jumping, you can lose weight successfully.pondering the BB online training program Longmen seat sit down 3 canned heat going up the country movie 10 sitting rowing 3 10 standing dumbbell bent http://www.countryheatbeachbody.com/ rowing 3 10 standing barbell barbell bent 3 10 sitting dumbbell curl 3 10 fifth days, after work, capable and well proportioned,A complete fitness program should country heat 2004 include three aspects: country heat calendar eating (eating) Diet: eat more,lead: many college students have asked for their fitness program After 12 weeks.the oblique dumbbell bench press (Group 4 Tianjin gas. http://cgi.members.interq.or.jp/silv...-bin/petit.cgi http://www.fanyongw.net/forum.php?mo...89&fromuid=285 http://www.journalistrates.com/index.php?item/106899 http://www.community.goplantbased.co...ile.php?id=607 http://clbs.mobi/cnlbs/space.php?uid...log&id=3074796 http://www.soubat.com/xinshou/1209 http://www.szsylm.com/forum.php?mod=...read&tid=30663 http://xn--4-stbop.xn--p1ai/forum/profile/d6f8aci3e7 http://tournamentsunited.com/forum/index.php?tid=41049 http://www.kaiboedu.com/plus/feedback.php?aid=29 http://www.bbs.mastergou.com/forum.p...age=1#pid80780 http://bbs.shiyebian.org/home.php?mo...c=blog&blogid= http://www.vanforfun.com/forum.php?m...age=1#pid90909 http://sfj88.com/forum.php?mod=viewt...id=6916&extra= http://fen.ege.edu.tr/~hsirin/index....38725#msg38725 http://www.msoer.cn/plus/feedback.php?aid=299 http://vanforfun.com/forum.php?mod=v...xtra=#pid90302 http://park1.aeonnet.ne.jp/~kino/cgi...fd/pfdbook.cgi http://www13.plala.or.jp/white_roots/gwbbs/gwbbs.cgi http://www.sxpac.com/home.php?mod=sp...ward=1&id=3726 http://www.rojiang.com/forum.php?mod...&fromuid=28039 http://www.pz4z.cn/wygkcn_GuestBook.asp http://a.allfans.cn/forum.php?mod=vi...age=1#pid24863 http://nbl-elec.com/plus/feedback.php?aid=149 http://yxhauto.com/archives/view-569323-1.html
Q6h4DZq1T3 is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply



Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 17:55.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.