Go Back   Palimpsest > Reviews > Book Reviews

a clash of kings, a feast for crows, a game of thrones, a song of ice and fire, a storm of swords, george r.r. martin

Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 13th Feb 2012, 13:32   #1
Senior Palimpsester

has the freedom of Palimp City
Noumenon's Avatar
Join Date: 13 Jul 2006
Location: Madrid, Spain
Posts: 3,793
Default George R.R. Martin: A Song of Fire & Ice

At the end of 2011 someone gave me an article to read, literally torn out of their copy of The New YorkerThe Dragon’s Egg, by Adam Gopnik. Always good to start with a digression, I think. It discusses why two particular pinnacles of teen literature (let’s not name names, but one features sparkingly sexualised vampires and the other misspells “dragon”) are as popular as they are among their respective readerships, despite their generally questioned literary qualities. To give a thumbnail of the argument, it first suggests that female teens are primarily looking for something that speaks to them emotionally, and that whatever sins the Twilight series (oops) might hide within its covers, it hits the raging hormonal maelstrom target dead on. Secondly, it claims that what young male readers most connect to in high fantasy is the discovery of an iconic history, with sequences eagerly committed to memory the way English school pupils were once expected to memorise the order of Kings and Queens, and that powerful weapons or significant battles seem far more valued than authentic depths of character in the heroes or villains. Though I have read neither Stephenie Meyer nor Christopher Paolini’s (ah well) Eragon books and am unlikely to do so, I found the argument, this division of focus, interesting. What strange things teenaged readers are, eh?

One other name that featured regularly in the article was that of J. R. R. Tolkien, and that name also appears prominently somewhere else: inside and outside the covers of the only-one-word-for-it epic fantasy series A Song of Ice and Fire by George R. R. Martin (no apparent relation), of which seven volumes are planned, number six is being written, five have been published, four read by me, and ten (episodes) broadcast in HBO’s fantastic adaptation of the first instalment, A Game of Thrones. It says something that, coming to that book almost directly after watching the series, it proved no disappointment at all. I can’t speak to the accuracy of the parallels with English history, although better informed viewers than myself have suggested them to be both reasonable and deliberate. What I can say is that, in the murky depths of its many characters and the breadth of ferocious action, A Song of Ice and Fire seems to have it all: sex, violence, passion, bad-language – teenagers ought to love it.

Everyone seems to love it. I love it. So what’s the problem?

The grand sweep of the action tells a story of royal families and factions at war, and despite the rich heritage of pseudo-medieval fantasy that has come before it there is no sensation of treading old ground. As the initial groups of characters divide and scatter throughout their world we are carried with them along many different storylines, events weaving around to influence each other, some threads cut short, new ones beginning. Hints of actual magic are tantalisingly few and far between, at least at first, and any hint of a Tolkienesque conflict between Good and Evil is lost almost as soon as the battle lines are drawn: allegiances are fluid on all sides, there are honourable figures and unknown betrayers in every court, all offering loyal service – and there are thousands of common men and women paying the price in death and destruction as their lords move the pieces, oblivious.

From the very beginning of A Game of Thrones the characterisation is varied and intriguing, not to mention intriguingly variable. There are children, teens, adults and ancients at play, but few are obvious in their motivations and fewer are static; Objectives and loyalties are realised or unveiled, switched or sacrificed, rarely achieved and more often thwarted, sometimes terminally. The first time an apparently significant person ended their involvement in a spray of blood it was genuinely stunning – perhaps, thinks the reader, no-one in this world is safe. As the series continues this proves true, sometimes shockingly so. That unfinished plans and dreams offer these people no protection from the contrary plans of their rivals, or simply from chance misfortune, brings a layer of real-world authenticity that is somehow more troubling than satisfying; we are used to even our heroes being sacrificed to a cause, but rarely to the causes themselves being cut off in their prime. What is the real story being told here amidst the many that die by the wayside? What is it actually about?

Over the course of reading I realised that this, for me, is the problem. While the teen-aged boy I once was is no doubt enraptured by the scope of conflict that is still unfolding four books in, and though the psychological teen-aged girl lurking in some clouded nook or cranny of my personality is surely thrilled to a flutter by all the passion and treachery, there is another part of me – is it the adult? – that takes up a book in search of something bigger than battles, bigger even than mere human feelings. I read for the exploration of some thing, some concept to be tested to destruction, some statement of position to be agreed with or found wanting. Not just to know who wins, but to discover some point, however simplistic. Isn’t that what stories are, what distinguishes them from mere history: not just events, but events with meaning?

What a problem, one that has had me hungrily reading four gigantic novels, and will certainly bring me running to hopefully three more. A Song of Ice and Fire is just great. No question. I’d recommend it to anyone. Honestly, as a contemporary work not hindered by the style of an earlier time, I find it a more satisfying read than The Lord of the Rings. But, in being not about simple Good Versus Evil but presenting through its fantasy something more earthily real, I wonder if come the final page it will prove only to be the record of who won, a vibrant, tumultuous history which never really happened.

Last edited by Noumenon; 13th Feb 2012 at 14:21. Reason: Spelling, etc.
Noumenon is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 14th Feb 2012, 18:20   #2
Junior Palimpsestarian
is a Regular
Join Date: 27 Apr 2011
Location: Inside my skin (Help!)
Posts: 144
Default Re: A Song of Ice and Fire - George R.R. Martin

Hi Noumenon,
This is an excellent essay in consideration of intriguing matters. I agree, we most of us want something more than a chronicle; but sometimes the research (or imagination)+ writing is good enough to carry us on. At least then the time spent is not a total loss. Some books of supposedly great moral or social import bore me to distraction and make me thin, So . . .what?, at the end. (I say this now just before I delve into DFW's Infinite Jest.)
In any case, your essay is very fine indeed and right on target.
"Anyone can run to excesses,
It is easy to shoot past the mark,
It is hard to stand firm in the middle." (E. Pound) | My Palimplist| Blog
kjml is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15th Feb 2012, 10:58   #3
eats too much cheese
m.'s Avatar
Join Date: 22 Nov 2003
Location: Poland
Posts: 1,300
Default Re: A Song of Ice and Fire - George R.R. Martin

Originally Posted by kjml View Post
Some books of supposedly great moral or social import bore me to distraction and make me thin, (...)
If only books could do that! Imagine all those models and pop celebrities with the Dostoyevsky volumes (or whatever they thought would work) in hands...

m. is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 18th Feb 2012, 15:41   #4
is beyond help
Colyngbourne's Avatar
Join Date: 30 Apr 2003
Location: England
Posts: 10,739
Default Re: A Song of Ice and Fire - George R.R. Martin

I think you're spot on, Nou. My teens - both sexes - love Game of Thrones (TV series and books) to distraction but beneath it all, I am hoping for some examination of something or other, some introspection or encounter or theorising about the tide of power and history that will provoke more thought than the simple luxury of a well-acted, well-constructed medieval epic.

It is the only thing that has made me change my desktop image for the first time in possibly 10 years from its usual C19th painting to a pic of Ned Stark with the Stark motto alongside
Currently reading: The Woman in White - Wilkie Collins | My reading list | My film list
Colyngbourne is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 19th Feb 2012, 14:20   #5
Junior Palimpsestarian
is a Regular
Join Date: 27 Apr 2011
Location: Inside my skin (Help!)
Posts: 144
Default Re: A Song of Ice and Fire - George R.R. Martin

Quite all right, m; funny and very observant too. BTW, one could certainly work off a few pounds carting around Hugo's masterworks.
"Anyone can run to excesses,
It is easy to shoot past the mark,
It is hard to stand firm in the middle." (E. Pound) | My Palimplist| Blog
kjml is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 19th Feb 2012, 19:52   #6
eats too much cheese
Join Date: 26 Nov 2004
Location: Toronto
Posts: 1,282
Default Re: A Song of Ice and Fire - George R.R. Martin

My son and I became OBSESSED with the series, both novels and television, last year. But we both agreed that as it goes on, we've red all five books, it loses direction and the plot start to become almost arbitrary. I've said that I won't even bother reading the next book, but no doubt, by the time it comes out, I will.

For those of you who love to cook, there is a fabulous web site call The Inn At The Crossroads (In the game of food, you win or you wash the dishes!) that is replicating the recipes described in the novels- even those with rather, er, unorthodox ingredients, such as dog and locust.
currently reading: The Secret History, Donna Tartt
Oryx is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 19th Feb 2012, 22:59   #7
Junior Palimpsestarian
is starting to settle in
Join Date: 12 Jul 2010
Posts: 18
Default Re: A Song of Ice and Fire - George R.R. Martin

I'm a huge fan of the first three books but definitely felt things went off kilter from four onwards. Four seemed a bit of a haphazard mess, ignoring what was going on with half of the characters, killing a couple of major characters off screen (so to speak), introducing lots of unnecessary extras and just going nowhere fast. Five seemed pretty much the same what with chapter after chapter passing without any significant plot advancement.

You start to get the feeling this was originally intended as a five book series, but GRRM felt like extending it to seven only he couldn't be bothered to write any more storyline so just made the plot of four drag out for two books. Part of me is still looking forward to books six and seven, and I still want to see how everything ends up, but I'm a lot less excited about this series than I was a decade ago.
Davidw is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 22nd Feb 2012, 11:59   #8
Junior Palimpsestarian
is new to Palimpsest
Join Date: 1 May 2011
Location: Barcelona
Posts: 6
Default Re: A Song of Ice and Fire - George R.R. Martin

Nice review, Noumenon. I read the second book after watching the series: I tried to start the first one but found that I wasn't interested in reading if I knew what happened. Which kind of sums it up for me - lots of fun, but I was very aware that I was pressing onwards for sake of the plot rather than anything else.
Fight the Landlord
michaelS is offline   Reply With Quote

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
A Month of Horror '11 bill Book Reviews 93 3rd Nov 2011 4:21
Martin Carthy at the Regent, Doncaster Allan Other Reviews 4 26th Sep 2008 1:04
The Dowie Neuk Stewart Features 6 19th Sep 2006 13:04

All times are GMT +1. The time now is 21:13.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2018, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.